UMD Dying Off?
Interestingly I was musing on this very subject earlier today, whilst browsing at my local DVD chain store. Carlo over at TechDirt has posted about the proprietary anture of the UMD, how it only works on one device, and that’s locked solely to the PSP for the same cost as a standard DVD.
My musings were brought about whilst looking at the Serenity DVD (which I already own), alongside it’s UMD version. Now, the DVD was a quite pleasant £14.99, which is about average for chart DVDs at this particular chain store. It had all the nice extra features that come with DVD releases (Outtakes, interviews and so on), whereas the UMD (which apparently doesn’t have special features) weighed in at £19.99.
So, for £5 extra in price, I get less content, and can view it in less places than I can the DVD.
So whilst I agree that proprietary formats are not the best idea, I think the primary reason for the failure of the UMD format is most assuredly price. Now, if they had them for sale at £9.99, then I’d probably start buying them. As it stands, if I have the choice of buying the DVD version or the UMD version, first choice will always be the DVD.





